The Doctor's Dilemma main backdrop
The Doctor's Dilemma main poster

The Doctor's Dilemma

Visit website

6.1/10 • 8

1959-01-011h 39m

DramaComedy

Four doctors face a serious dilemma when the beautiful wife of a TB-stricken artist begs one of them to cure her brilliant, but amoral, husband.

Directors
Anthony Asquith
Editors
Gordon Hales

Top Billed Cast

View Credits
  1. Dirk Bogarde

    Dirk Bogarde

    Louis Dubedat

  2. Leslie Caron

    Leslie Caron

    Mrs. Dubedat

  3. Alastair Sim

    Alastair Sim

    Cutler Walpole

  4. Alec McCowen

    Alec McCowen

    Redpenny

  5. Robert Morley

    Robert Morley

    Sir Ralph Bloomfield-Bonington

  6. Felix Aylmer

    Felix Aylmer

    Sir Patrick Cullen

  7. Michael Gwynn

    Michael Gwynn

    Dr. Blenkinsop

  8. Maureen Delaney

    Maureen Delaney

    Emmy

Reviews1

View Reviews
barrymost Avatar

barrymost

Oct 25, 2022

7/10

G.B. Shaw does not disappoint! Some may find this adaptation of Shaw's stage play rather slow, talky, and even boring. True, its stage roots are very evident, but the discriminating viewer (or film connoisseur, if you're like me) will find much to appreciate. Brilliant young artist Louis Dubedat (Dirk Bogarde) suffers from bad luck, bad income, and bad health. When he starts coughing up a lung, his devoted wife (Leslie Caron) approaches a recently knighted doctor who claims to have a cure for TB. But the doctor has a limit as to how many patients he can cure, and so he gathers three of his friends to get their opinions on his prospective new patient. After interviewing Dubedat, they don't particularly like what they see. Now the quartet of doctors (Alistair Sim, Robert Morley, John Robinson, and Felix Aylmer) face a moral dilemma: what constitutes the worth of a life - moral character, or sheer brilliance? Bottom line is, this film deserves a higher average rating than it gets on most film sites. Is it great? Maybe not, but it's certainly very good. Caron may be a bit stiff here, but the two standouts in the cast are Bogarde and Sim: two of the greatest actors to come out of the UK. The former is a lovable, carefree renegade who "doesn't believe in morality", while the latter is an eccentric quack who has an obsession with blood poisoning. (Spoilers ahead) I can't in good conscience write this review without mentioning the death scene. As it turns out, the doctors opt to let Dubedat die, so that the Mrs. may never know about his faults - which include, but are not limited to, petty theft and bigamy. He lies on his deathbed, conveying his last wishes to his wife, in a scene that goes on . . . and on . . . and on. It really is ridiculously long and cringe-worthy, but you get the sense that it was done on purpose. It's bad, but it's supposed to be bad. I even found myself bursting out laughing in the middle of it. It's quite possibly the worst case of scenery chewing I've ever witnessed in a movie. Dirk Bogarde doesn't just chew the scenery, he spits it out too! You can tell he's having fun and milking it for all it's worth, making it all the more memorable. This film comes recommended to you by yours truly, P.M. Turner

Media

  • The Doctor's Dilemma poster
  • The Doctor's Dilemma poster
  • The Doctor's Dilemma poster

Recommendations

  • Granit main backdrop

    Granit

    7.3

  • The Silent Twins main backdrop

    The Silent Twins

    6.7

  • New Gods: Yang Jian main backdrop

    New Gods: Yang Jian

    7.4

  • Suitable Flesh main backdrop

    Suitable Flesh

    5.4

  • way main backdrop

    way

    5.7

  • The Apology main backdrop

    The Apology

    6.2

  • Venus main backdrop

    Venus

    6.3

  • Fullmetal Alchemist: The Revenge of Scar main backdrop

    Fullmetal Alchemist: The Revenge of Scar

    6.6

  • New Beginnings main backdrop

    New Beginnings

    5.8

  • Shamshera main backdrop

    Shamshera

    5.5

  • House of Spoils main backdrop

    House of Spoils

    5.6

  • Justice main backdrop

    Justice

    6.6

  • There Are No Saints main backdrop

    There Are No Saints

    5.2

  • Les Indésirables main backdrop

    Les Indésirables

    6.1

  • Dave Chappelle: The Dreamer main backdrop

    Dave Chappelle: The Dreamer

    6.9

  • Mobile Suit Gundam SEED FREEDOM main backdrop

    Mobile Suit Gundam SEED FREEDOM

    6.7

  • Party Hard, Die Young main backdrop

    Party Hard, Die Young

    4.8

  • Le Clan main backdrop

    Le Clan

    6.7

  • Terrestrial Verses main backdrop

    Terrestrial Verses

    7.5

  • WWE Survivor Series: WarGames 2022 main backdrop

    WWE Survivor Series: WarGames 2022

    7.7

Status
Released
Original Language
English
Budget
--
Revenue
--
Keywords
dying and deathhusband wife relationshipmoral ambiguityartistpainterbased on play or musicaldoctortuberculosismedical drama